Reconstruction analysis
Notes
This root is attested in the NE Indian Areal Group, Nungish, and perhaps Qiangic, as well as in Himalayish (Hayu, Tshona). The proto-initial seems to have been *r-, though some reflexes have l-. It is possible that there is a connection with *s-lum or *z-lum ‘round’ (STC #143).
Chinese comparandum
卵 OC *lwɑ̂n, GSR #179a ‘egg; testicle’; Li 1971: *luanx; Baxter 1992 #557: *g-ronʔ; Mand. luǎn.
In Baxter’s system, MC l- is always derived from OC *C-r-, that is, an initial r with a prefixed consonant (to be distinguished from *Cr- in which r functions as a medial). In other systems, MC l- may descend from simple initial *r-. Baxter 1992 gives two separate reconstructions for this word: *g-ronʔ (#557) and *C-ronʔ (#949, with *C unspecified). There is some reason to suppose that if the prefix *C- is to be reconstructed it would be a velar (Baxter 1992:387).
The correspondence between PTB *r- and Middle Chinese l- is well-attested. Although both the Chinese and PTB forms have a rounded vowel and a nasal final, the correspondences are problematic. No generally accepted OC/PTB cognates show an *-n/*-m correspondence. OC *ua (Li 1971) / *o (Baxter 1992) generally corresponds to PTB *o, not *u; for example, 脫 OC *hluat ‘remove’ (Li 1971); PTB *hlot; Mand. tuō. We would expect PTB rhyme *-um to correspond to OC *-əm (Li 1971); see examples in Gong 1995.
Gong 1995 #41 compares Chinese 卵, which he reconstructs *ruanx, with Written Tibetan sro-ma ‘nit’ (see #1172 PTB *s-row EGG / NIT, below), following Benedict 1976:190 (“Sino-Tibetan: another look”). Schuessler 2007:369 makes the same comparison, citing PTB *(s-)rwa rather than *s-row. For this comparison to hold, a nominalizing *-n suffix must be posited for the Chinese form (Schuessler 2007:74-75).
[ZJH]
Reflexes & cognates37 reflexes · 9 subgroups
1.1“North Assam”2
1.3.3Zeme Group1
1.4Meithei2
2.1.2Bodic3
3.2Qiangic4
4Nungic7
5Tujia14
9.0.1Old Chinese3
9.0.3Modern Chinese1
Cite this entry
*(r/l)um ‘EGG’.https://larc-iu.github.io/stedt/etymon/3438BibTeX
@misc{stedt-3438,
title = {{*(r/l)um 'EGG'}},
author = {STEDT},
year = {2017},
note = {Sino-Tibetan Etymological Dictionary and Thesaurus (STEDT) v1.0, etymon #3438},
url = {https://larc-iu.github.io/stedt/etymon/3438}
}